· by Michael Blair, Nashville's Chimney Sweep
A gas fireplace that suddenly smells sends most people to the same worry: is it leaking? Sometimes it is, and that case has one right answer. Far more often the smell has a plainer cause, and the manual for the logs says so in its troubleshooting pages. Here is what one manufacturer’s manual for its vent-free gas logs says about each kind of odor, which ones you can deal with yourself, and which ones mean a fireplace repair visit.
Is a gas smell from the fireplace ever normal?
No. A smell of gas means you leave the fireplace off and get out of the way of it. Superior’s installation and operation manual for its NF18 and NF24 vent-free gas logs sets out the order: shut off the gas, light nothing, leave electric switches alone and use no phone inside the building, then call the gas supplier from a neighbor’s phone and do what they say. If the supplier cannot be reached, it says to call the fire department.
The manual also explains why your nose is not a reliable alarm. Natural gas and propane have no smell of their own; an odorant is added so leaks can be noticed, and that odor can fade, so gas can be present with nothing to smell. Before lighting, it tells owners to smell all around the appliance and down at the floor, because some gas is heavier than air and settles low.
What is the smell from a new gas log set?
A new gas log set gives off a break-in smell while the logs cure, and in Superior’s manual it is short-lived. The manual says that during the first operation of a new heater, the logs give off a smell like burning paper with an orange flame, that opening the damper or a window vents it, and that it lasts only a few hours. It adds that light smoking can happen at first while the logs cure and leftover manufacturing residue burns off.
That is one maker’s figure for one vent-free product, and vented and direct-vent fireplaces carry their own manuals, so check yours for the break-in period it gives. What the Superior manual is clear about is the end of it: these logs are designed to burn without smoke, and if they ever appear to smoke after that, the heater should be turned off and a qualified service person called.
What else in the room can make gas logs smell?
Fumes already in the room are the cause the Superior manual names most often. Its troubleshooting section says that cleaning supplies, paint, paint remover, cigarette smoke, cements and glues, and new carpet or fabrics all give off vapors that mix with the air the flame burns and come out as odor. The fix it gives is to open a window and stop using those products while the heater runs, and it says the odors fade over time. Its installation notes add aromatic candles, cleaning fluids and oil or kerosene lamps to the list of airborne impurities that can cause odors or discolor walls.
Two more causes are worth knowing. The manual says to turn the logs off before using furniture polish, wax, carpet cleaner or similar products, because heated vapors from them can leave a white powder in the burner box or on nearby walls and furniture. On a propane set, it lists a low fuel supply among the causes of unwanted odor, and the remedy is a tank refill.
Which smells mean a repair, not a fresh-air fix?
A gas odor with the control knob in the off position is a repair, and so is a gas odor while the logs are burning. Superior’s troubleshooting table traces the first to a gas leak or a faulty control valve, and the second to a leak or foreign matter in the gas line between the valve and the burner. The same manual tells owners not to try a repair themselves or use tools on the controls, warning that force or a home repair attempt can cause a fire or an explosion.
No smell tells you about carbon monoxide. The EPA’s carbon monoxide page describes it as odorless and colorless, which is why the Tennessee State Fire Marshal’s Office recommends carbon monoxide alarms outside each sleeping area and on every level, and a professional inspection of fuel-burning equipment each year before the cold arrives. Our post on servicing a gas fireplace covers that yearly visit. If the smell is a repair, ask us for an estimate once the gas company has cleared the house.
Sources
- Superior Fireplaces, Installation and Operation Instructions, Unvented (Vent-Free) Gas Log Heaters NF18 and NF24 (P/N 901336-00 Rev. A, July 2025) — What to do if you smell gas; odorant can fade; smell near the floor before lighting; paper-burning break-in smell for a few hours and slight smoking while logs cure; smoking logs mean turn off and call service; room fumes, candles and lamps cause odors; turn off before polish, wax or carpet cleaner; low propane causes odor; gas odor with knob off or during burn traced to leak, control valve or foreign matter; no home repairs or tools
- U.S. EPA, Carbon Monoxide’s Impact on Indoor Air Quality — Carbon monoxide is odorless, colorless and toxic
- Tennessee State Fire Marshal’s Office, SFMO shares safety tips on Carbon Monoxide Awareness Day (September 18, 2018) — CO alarms outside each sleeping area and on every level; yearly professional inspection of fuel-burning heating equipment and chimneys before cold weather
FAQ
Why a Gas Fireplace Smells, and When It Is Gas — questions
Why does my gas fireplace smell?
Usually for a plain reason. Superior’s vent-free log manual lists break-in odor on new logs, fumes from paint, cleaners, glues, new carpet or smoke in the room, and a low propane tank. A smell of gas is different: leave the fireplace off and call the gas company from outside the house.
Should a gas fireplace smell like gas?
No. A gas smell means shut off the gas, light nothing, touch no electric switches, and call the gas supplier from a neighbor’s phone, as Superior’s manual directs, or the fire department if the supplier cannot be reached. The added odorant can also fade, so the absence of a smell does not prove there is no leak.
How long does a new gas log set smell?
Superior’s manual says its new logs give off a paper-burning smell, with an orange flame, for only a few hours, and that opening the damper or a window vents it. Other makers give their own break-in periods, so check the manual for your set. Smoke that continues after break-in means turning the logs off and calling for service.
What should I do if I smell gas near my fireplace?
Do not light anything, do not use electric switches or any phone in the house, and call your gas supplier from a neighbor’s phone, then follow their instructions. Superior’s manual adds shutting off the gas supply and calling the fire department if the supplier cannot be reached. Have the fireplace repaired before it is used again.
Can gas logs smell from paint fumes or candles in the room?
Yes. Superior’s manual says vapors from paint, cleaners, glues, cigarette smoke and new carpet mix with the air the flame burns and cause odors, and its installation notes add aromatic candles and oil lamps. Open a window and stop using those products while the logs burn; the manual says the odors fade.