· by Michael Blair, Nashville's Chimney Sweep
A house with a fireplace goes under contract, the home inspection comes back, and the chimney section says little more than that the chimney was viewed. That is usually not a careless inspector. It is the edge of what a Tennessee home inspection has to include, and the inside of the flue sits outside it. Here is where that line falls, what the Chimney Safety Institute of America recommends when a property changes hands, and how to fit a chimney inspection into the days a contract allows.
Does a home inspector inspect the chimney?
Only the parts that are readily visible. The Tennessee Department of Commerce and Insurance’s rules for home inspectors have the inspector look at chimneys, flues and vents where they can readily be seen, and say the inspector is not required to inspect the interior of flues or the flue connections of a fireplace insert, or to light or put out a solid fuel fire. The version the Secretary of State publishes is dated September 2006 (Revised).
The same rules count masonry and factory-built fireplaces, inserts and stoves as solid fuel heating devices, so the limit applies to the ordinary brick fireplace in a living room as much as to a wood stove. In practice a home inspection can describe the crown, the brick above the roofline and the firebox, and still say nothing about the liner the smoke actually travels through.
Which chimney inspection is recommended when a house is sold?
A Level 2. The Chimney Safety Institute of America’s standard operating procedure for a Level 2 inspection of a masonry chimney, revised in 2019, says a Level 2 is also recommended when the property is being sold. It lists other occasions for one too: replacing an appliance with one of a different kind, relining, and after a chimney fire, a weather or seismic event, or a malfunction. That is the institute’s recommendation, and the buyer or seller decides whether to order one.
The levels themselves are set out in our post on what a chimney inspection covers. For a sale, the points that matter are these: a Level 2 takes in all the accessible parts of the fireplace, the chimney and any connected appliance, including the attic, basement and crawl space it passes through, and the procedure requires a video scan of the chimney interior. If a flue cannot be scanned, because of its size or several offsets, the report has to say so.
Why does the camera matter in a home sale?
Because the inside of the flue is exactly what the home inspection is allowed to leave out. Damage partway up a flue does not show from the firebox or from the top of the chimney, and the video scan is the step in a Level 2 that reaches it.
What the scan finds can change the negotiation. A flue that needs relining is a bigger job than a cracked crown or loose brick, and our chimney liner page covers what that work involves. A Level 2 also takes longer than the look that comes with a sweep, reaches more of the house and includes the camera run, which is why it is priced as its own service.
Fitting it into the contract
For a buyer, the inspection period is short, so ask for the chimney inspection at the same time as the home inspection rather than after the report comes back. Access is the seller’s to give, and the fireplace should be cold, so ask that no fire be lit in the day or two before. Bring the inspection report’s chimney notes; they tell us what the home inspector could and could not see.
For a seller, an inspection before listing answers the question before a buyer asks it, and leaves time to make repairs on your own schedule. We do inspections from Franklin to Columbia and across Middle Tennessee. Ask for a Level 2 inspection and tell us the closing date, whether the fireplace burns wood or gas, and whether there is an insert or a stove in it.
Sources
- Chimney Safety Institute of America, Level 2 Inspection, Masonry Chimney Attached to a Building Heating Appliance (Rev. 4/5/19) — Level 2 recommended when the property is being sold and after other listed events; scope includes attic, basement and crawl space; video scanning of the chimney interior required; report must state when a flue could not be scanned.
- Tennessee Department of Commerce and Insurance, Rules Chapter 0780-5-12, Home Inspectors — Standards of practice: chimneys, flues and vents inspected where readily visible; inspector not required to inspect flue interiors or insert flue connections, or to ignite or extinguish solid fuel fires; definition of solid fuel heating device. Published version dated September 2006 (Revised).
FAQ
Chimney Inspection When Buying or Selling a House — questions
What is the difference between a level 1 and level 2 chimney inspection?
A Level 1 looks at the readily accessible parts of the chimney and the appliance. A Level 2 adds all accessible parts of the fireplace, chimney and connected appliances, including attic, basement and crawl space areas, and the CSIA procedure requires a video scan of the chimney interior. The CSIA recommends a Level 2 when a property is sold.
Does a home inspector light the fireplace?
Not necessarily. Tennessee’s standards of practice for home inspectors say the inspector is not required to ignite or extinguish a solid fuel fire, and is not required to inspect the interior of flues or the flue connections of a fireplace insert. The chimney is inspected where it is readily visible.
Why does a level 2 chimney inspection cost more than a sweep?
It is more work. A Level 2 covers every accessible part of the fireplace, chimney and connected appliances, including the attic, basement and crawl space, and the CSIA procedure requires a video scan of the chimney interior. The sweep’s own look is limited to what can be seen from the existing openings.
Can every chimney flue be scanned with a camera?
Not always. The CSIA’s Level 2 procedure recognizes that a flue may be too small to scan or may have several offsets the camera cannot pass. In that case the report has to say that the interior could not be scanned, so a buyer knows which part of the chimney was not seen.